American Van Lines vs Mayflower Transit
2026 comparison for Florida moves · Updated July 2026
American Van Lines (USDOT #614506) scores 9.0/10 vs Mayflower Transit (USDOT #077949) at 8.6/10 — fact-based scoring using FMCSA records, BBB data, and 11,500+ combined consumer reviews. Both are licensed for Florida moves.
- ✓ Ratings: American ⭐ 4.4/5 (4,300 reviews) vs Mayflower ⭐ 4.3/5 (7,200 reviews)
- ✓ BBB: American A+ vs Mayflower A · Both USDOT active
- ✓ Binding estimates: American Yes ✓ · Mayflower Yes ✓
- ✓ Price tiers: American (mid) · Mayflower (mid) · Deposit: 10% vs None
Compare Free Quotes
Get quotes from American Van Lines, Mayflower Transit & more.
American Van Lines
Best for Antiques & Pianos
FMCSA Verification
American Van Lines
USDOT #614506 · MC-330861
active authority · Insurance on file ✓
FMCSA Verification
Mayflower Transit
USDOT #077949 · MC-6325
active authority · Insurance on file ✓
Key Metrics Comparison
| Metric | American Van Lines | Mayflower Transit |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 9.0/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Composite Rating | ⭐ 4.4 | ⭐ 4.3 |
| Review Count | 4,300 | 7,200 |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A |
| Price Range | mid | mid |
| Deposit Required | 10% | None |
| Binding Estimates | Yes | Yes |
| USDOT Status | active | active |
| Headquartered | Pompano Beach, FL | Fenton, MO |
| Founded | 1995 | 1927 |
| USDOT Number | #614506 | #077949 |
| Insurance on File | Yes ✓ | Yes ✓ |
Score Breakdown (0–5)
American Van Lines
Pros
- ✓Florida-based carrier (Pompano Beach)
- ✓Certified piano and antique movers
- ✓Background-checked employees
- ✓Binding estimates
- ✓A+ BBB rating
Cons
- ✗10% deposit required
- ✗Not the cheapest option
- ✗Limited to 48 contiguous states
Mayflower Transit
Pros
- ✓Nearly 100 years of experience
- ✓No deposit required
- ✓Binding estimates
- ✓Strong brand accountability
Cons
- ✗Under same parent as United Van Lines — similar limitations
- ✗No instant online pricing
- ✗Agent inconsistency
American Van Lines is Best For
Mayflower Transit is Best For
Services Offered
American Van Lines
- ✓ Long-distance moving
- ✓ Interstate moving
- ✓ Piano moving
- ✓ Antique moving
- ✓ Packing services
- ✓ Storage
- ✓ Last-minute moving
Mayflower Transit
- ✓ Long-distance moving
- ✓ Interstate moving
- ✓ Packing services
- ✓ Storage
- ✓ Auto transport
- ✓ Corporate relocation
Our Verdict
Choose American Van Lines if you...
- → Need pianos
- → Need antiques
- → Need valuable items
- → Need south florida moves
- → Want a FL-headquartered carrier
Choose Mayflower Transit if you...
- → Need name-brand reliability
- → Need traditional full-service moves
- → Want no upfront deposit
How We Score Florida Movers
Our 10-point overall score combines five equally-weighted categories (each 0–5) using FMCSA records, BBB complaint data, and verified consumer review aggregates. Updated quarterly.
Pricing
Cost vs. market avg, transparency, binding estimate availability
Reliability
FMCSA complaint rate, on-time delivery, damage claim rate
Customer Service
Responsiveness, claims handling, review consistency
Services
Range: packing, storage, specialty, international coverage
Transparency
USDOT disclosure, written estimates, deposit policy clarity