American Van Lines vs Mayflower Transit
2026 comparison for Florida moves · Updated May 2026
⭐ Top Pick
American Van Lines
Best for Antiques & Pianos
9.0 / 10 overall score
⭐ 4.4 BBB A+ FL-based
Key Metrics Comparison
| Metric | American Van Lines | Mayflower Transit |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 9.0/10 | 8.6/10 |
| Composite Rating | ⭐ 4.4 | ⭐ 4.3 |
| Review Count | 4,300 | 7,200 |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A |
| Price Range | mid | mid |
| Deposit Required | 10% | None |
| Binding Estimates | Yes | Yes |
| USDOT Status | active | active |
| Headquartered | Pompano Beach, FL | Fenton, MO |
| Founded | 1995 | 1927 |
Score Breakdown (0–5)
Pricing
American: 4.2 Mayflower: 4.0
Reliability
American: 4.5 Mayflower: 4.3
Customer Service
American: 4.5 Mayflower: 4.2
Services Offered
American: 4.8 Mayflower: 4.7
Transparency
American: 4.7 Mayflower: 4.4
American Van Lines
Pros
- ✓Florida-based carrier (Pompano Beach)
- ✓Certified piano and antique movers
- ✓Background-checked employees
- ✓Binding estimates
- ✓A+ BBB rating
Cons
- ✗10% deposit required
- ✗Not the cheapest option
- ✗Limited to 48 contiguous states
Mayflower Transit
Pros
- ✓Nearly 100 years of experience
- ✓No deposit required
- ✓Binding estimates
- ✓Strong brand accountability
Cons
- ✗Under same parent as United Van Lines — similar limitations
- ✗No instant online pricing
- ✗Agent inconsistency
American Van Lines is Best For
PianosAntiquesValuable itemsSouth Florida moves
Mayflower Transit is Best For
Name-brand reliabilityTraditional full-service moves
Services Offered
American Van Lines
- ✓ Long-distance moving
- ✓ Interstate moving
- ✓ Piano moving
- ✓ Antique moving
- ✓ Packing services
- ✓ Storage
- ✓ Last-minute moving
Mayflower Transit
- ✓ Long-distance moving
- ✓ Interstate moving
- ✓ Packing services
- ✓ Storage
- ✓ Auto transport
- ✓ Corporate relocation
Our Verdict
Choose American Van Lines if you...
- → Need pianos
- → Need antiques
- → Need valuable items
- → Need south florida moves
- → Want a FL-headquartered carrier
Choose Mayflower Transit if you...
- → Need name-brand reliability
- → Need traditional full-service moves
- → Want no upfront deposit
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better: American Van Lines or Mayflower Transit?
American Van Lines scores higher overall (9.0/10 vs 8.6/10). However, the best choice depends on your move type, budget, and timeline.
Does American Van Lines or Mayflower Transit have lower prices?
Both movers are in the same price tier (mid). Always get binding estimates from both before deciding.
Which mover has better reviews — American Van Lines or Mayflower Transit?
American Van Lines has a higher composite rating (4.4 vs 4.3). American Van Lines has 4,300 reviews and Mayflower Transit has 7,200 reviews.